Trump impeachment: White House withheld Ukraine aid just after Zelensky call
23-12-2019, 10:06

Font size: [ A+ ] / [ A- ]

The White House sought to freeze aid to Ukraine just 91 minutes after President Trump spoke to President Volodymyr Zelensky by phone in July, a newly-released government email has revealed.

In the call, Mr Trump asked the Ukrainian leader to investigate his political rival, Democrat Joe Biden.

Democrats say it shows Mr Trump used the office for personal political gain.

The fateful phone call is key to the abuse of power charge on which Mr Trump has been impeached.

A US whistleblower who heard about the conversation raised concerns, which ultimately triggered the impeachment inquiry.

Mr Trump was formally impeached by the Democratic-controlled House of Representatives on Wednesday, but is unlikely to be removed from office as the case will go to trial in the US Senate, where his Republican party has a majority.

 

What's in the email?

 

The newly-released email was obtained by the Center for Public Integrity following a court order in a freedom of information case.

It shows that a senior White House official, Mike Duffey, contacted senior defence officials about withholding Ukraine's aid just over an hour-and-a-half after Mr Trump ended a 25 July call with President Zelensky.

A rough transcript of that call was declassified by the White House following a whistleblower complaint it was being covered-up.

The transcript shows Mr Trump asked Mr Zelensky to "do us a favour" and investigate Joe Biden, currently a frontrunner to be the Democratic candidate in the 2020 White House race, and his son Hunter Biden, who had previously worked for a Ukrainian energy company.

In the email Mr Duffey asks that the Department of Defense "hold off" on providing aid following the administration's plan to review.

"Given the sensitive nature of the request, I appreciate your keeping that information closely held to those who need to know to execute direction," the email reads.

 

What has the reaction been?

 

Rachel Semmel, a spokeswoman for the Office of Management and Budget, dismissed the characterisation of the email in a statement to US media on Sunday.

"It's reckless to tie the hold of funds to the phone call. As has been established and publicly reported, the hold was announced in an interagency meeting on July 18," CNN quoted her as saying.

"To pull a line out of one email and fail to address the context is misleading and inaccurate."

 

Meanwhile the top Democrat in the US Senate, Chuck Schumer, said the email proved the need for new witnesses and evidence at President Trump's impeachment trial.

"If there was ever an argument that we need Mr Duffey to come and testify, this is that information. This email is explosive," Mr Schumer said.

"A top administration official, one that we requested, is saying, stop the aid 90 minutes after Trump called Zelensky and said keep it hush, hush. What more do you need to request a witness?"

"Until we hear from the witnesses, until we get the documents, the American people will correctly assume that those blocking their testimony were aiding and abetting a cover up, plain and simple," Mr Schumer added.

"So I'll close by saying this: President Trump, release the emails, let the witnesses testify, what are you afraid of?"

 

What happens next with impeachment?

 

The start date of the trial is in doubt, as partisan wrangling between the parties continues.

Mitch McConnell, the Republican majority leader who will determine the terms of the trial, wants the case to be considered without testimony.

But Democrats say new witnesses should be heard in the Senate, including at least four current and former White House aides with knowledge of the Ukraine affair.

They want Mr McConnell to clarify whose testimony will be allowed.

Nancy Pelosi, the Democratic Speaker of the House, has postponed sending the impeachment charges to the Senate until the rules of the Senate trial are acceptable to her party.

Mr Trump tweeted on Sunday that the Democrats' case in the "impeachment hoax" was "dead" and called Ms Pelosi "crazy Nancy".

Republicans currently hold 53 seats in the 100-seat chamber, making a conviction - which requires a two-thirds vote - extremely unlikely.

 

 

BBC

Comments: 216
#96   Marisa
      
https://rc.intaps.com/aracelykifer24


https://revenu.live/@roylivingston?page=about


https://www.e-vinil.ro/lynndonahue01


https://git.homains.org/raynoemi292030


http://182.43.16.183:3000/donnyrhs060736/6039235/wiki/Casinos+In+%2526+Near+Chic
ago%252C+IL+Area%252C+with+Map


https://gogs.ra-solutions.de/aaroncolmenero/blackcoin.co1982/wiki/30++Top+Real+M
oney+Australian+Online+Casinos+November%252C+2025


https://twoheartsagency.com/@adelaidas16492


http://shvber.com:5189/abbiepastor092/blackcoin.co4211/wiki/Online+Action+That+P
ays+in+Australia


http://121.196.213.68:3000/albertrapp1871


https://git.lakaweb.com/adriannekzv303/blackcoin.co3795/wiki/Crown-Melbourne-Wik
ipedia


https://gogs.spbda.ru/abbiex69422063


https://gitlab.jmarinecloud.com/xeprayford7272


https://social.oneworldonesai.com/read-blog/60648_skycity-adelaide-hotel-luxury-
stays-dining-amp-entertainment.html


https://www.virtualdatinghub.com/@tatianaranken


https://git.xzjz.cc/rosalindcharet/blackcoin.co4653/wiki/Fort+McDowell+Casino+Ne
ar+Scottsdale%252C+AZ


https://www.simpra.org:3000/altagrove47182


http://git.biscicloud.com/agustincogburn


https://gogs.spbda.ru/abbiex69422063


https://gitea.fuluzhanggui.com:99/jdbmichell6449


https://git.fhlz.top/lewisbrobst66


http://41.180.4.117:3000/adelaidedugas/blackcoin1981/wiki/Online-Casino-to-Play-
Slots-in-Australia

References:


101.200.243.208
22 November 2025 11:43
#95   Tiffiny
      
https://surily.in/katheringleeso


https://git.ajattix.org/xavierupton675


https://gogs.pinadshub.com/jacintogetz361


https://dreamplacesai.de/antoniafoltz9


https://git.fasteur.cn/rosalineperret


https://git.on58.com/adancade758371


https://git.futaihulian.com/chrisyce654343/5650671/-/issues/2


http://www.ggafrik.site/andresfierro4


https://meeting2up.it/@jpujenna13426


https://tweetchat.me/read-blog/1230_official-website.html


https://git.rikkei.edu.vn/giselethring5/blackcoin.co2094/-/issues/6


https://www.zhangertong.com/lorenzaquinn2


https://xajhuang.com:3100/bellesallee565


https://soundrecords.zamworg.com/michellarmytag


https://git.rec4box.com/diaahmad817795


https://twielo.com/read-blog/145_sgr-asx-casino-operator-ballys-corporation-chec
ks-out-australias-star-entertainm.html


https://git.siin.space/brookstrf34667


https://sistemagent.com:8081/hueyfarnsworth/blackcoin.co1990/wiki/Il+Miglior+Cas
in%C3%B2+Online+in+Italia+2025


https://slowdating.ca/@felipereitz306


https://gitea.b54.co/alvarolindsay


https://likeminds.fun/read-blog/81535_1968-tasmanian-casino-referendum-wikipedia
.html

References:


git.anibilag.ru
22 November 2025 03:11
#94   Saundra
      
https://cumbriasearch.co.uk/companies/best-online-casinos-in-australia-for-real-
money-in-2025/


https://pdq.ir/venuswaite


https://precise.co.za/employer/joe-fortune-casino-reviews-read-customer-service-
reviews-of-joe-fortune-casino-bet/


https://40tag.com/xxclawrenc


https://www.ayurjobs.net/employer/best-us-online-casinos-with-real-money-payouts
/


https://manpoweradvisors.com/employer/cairns-reef-hotel-casino/


https://lidmilink.ru/barneydegiller


https://www.gomyneed.com/profile/charlapeace275


https://wschang.synology.me/g5/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=3826


https://taiwanteachjobs.com/employer/best-real-money-online-casinos-in-the-us-20
25/


https://ahhhe.com/groups/best-online-live-casinos-2025-play-at-the-top-us-live-c
asinos


https://lidmilink.ru/barneydegiller


http://pasarinko.zeroweb.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=notice&wr_id=8009915


https://toto.bawok.me/freddielic5525


https://sun-clinic.co.il/he/question/king-billy-casino-australia-kingbilly-login
-games/


https://xsurl.in/stephen4508111


https://digital-skill-jobs.web-grafix.in/employer/sgr-asx-star-entertainments-my
stery-macau-backer-hikes-stake-for-second-time-in-a-week/


https://link-me.vip/elvinbolling60


https://ethiofarmers.com/2025-australia-legal-online-casinos-aussie-online-casin
os/


https://aparca.app/philipschreibe


https://hubu.ru/lorriechri

References:


gpyouhak.com
22 November 2025 01:24
#93   Phoebe
      
https://mozride.com/@micaelahardey3


https://www.aservicehost.ru/andredistefano


https://friends4ed.co.zw/read-blog/5131_fastpay-casino-reviews-read-customer-ser
vice-reviews-of-fastpay-casino-com.html


https://gitea.kdlsvps.top/arethaahmouy04


http://libochen.cn:13000/alvinmassey519/blackcoin.co1137/wiki/Fair+Go+Casino+Log
in


https://git.outsidecontext.solutions/teddythyer3229


https://talkkro.com/read-blog/7513_best-online-casino-for-aussie-pokies-amp-big-
wins.html


http://www.controlleriot.cn:3000/chasityhowells/chasity2023/wiki/Responsible-Gam
ing-Northern-Territory-Darwin-Casinos


http://git.edazone.cn/rickyloyd98598


https://git.lodis.se/tesha71l390611


https://repos.ubtob.net/alisachastain/alisa2007/wiki/Best+Online+Slots+in+Austra
lia


https://mxlinkin.mimeld.com/read-blog/28626_fair-go-casino-no-deposit-bonus-code
s-amp-review.html


http://222.85.191.97:5000/ettawnq562119


https://gitea.fuluzhanggui.com:99/angieisabelle


https://repo.apps.odatahub.net/marinahurd429


http://185.8.173.124:1304/javierfender2


https://gogs.pinadshub.com/deeslowik3616


https://git.sayndone.ru/jairbv63374008


http://libochen.cn:13000/alvinmassey519


https://git.koppa.pro/antoniastjohn/blackcoin8794/wiki/Welcome-Offer-a-100%25-ma
tch-up-to-1000-AUD


https://talkkro.com/read-blog/7647_casino-world.html

References:


gitea.wholelove.com.tw
21 November 2025 06:16
#92   Shawnee
      
https://git.fofpower.cn/leonardoforro9


http://89.58.12.121:3000/charitym195017


https://stevewpalmer.uk/alfredv7079120


https://freedost.com/read-blog/116549_rocketplay-casino-canada-best-rocketplay-c
asino-online-games-for-real-money.html


https://www.ilife24.com/fredyoul699151/blackcoin.co2014/wiki/Free+Slots+%2526+On
line+Social+Casino


https://aws-poc.xpresso.ai/gitlab/annismannix279


https://adilsokak.com/read-blog/1642_best-real-money-online-casinos-in-australia
-for-2025.html


https://freedost.com/read-blog/116549_rocketplay-casino-canada-best-rocketplay-c
asino-online-games-for-real-money.html


http://182.92.251.55:3000/enriquetadacom


https://www.finlandmlbforum.com/read-blog/3942_crown-resorts-wikipedia.html


http://8.142.81.167:1080/belleerwin408


http://gogs.cect360.com/taylorholler94/taylor2002/wiki/Play+%2526+Win+Big+Today%
2521


https://filuv.bnkode.com/@bettemallett6


https://www.hacheehouse.store/thaogooseberry


https://friendza.enroles.com/read-blog/92873_brisbanes-treasury-casino-closing-s
tar-brisbane-to-open.html


http://121.43.162.141:13000/arnulfosolorio/6878blackcoin/wiki/Play+Games%252C+Po
kies%252C+and+Slots+Online+in+Australia


https://network.musicdiffusion.com/read-blog/56661_10-best-casinos-near-me-ultim
ate-local-casino-guide-for-2025.html


https://zehabesha.org/read-blog/1744_sgr-asx-star-warns-of-urgent-cash-crunch-li
quidity-pain.html


http://git.suxiniot.com/adrianna84i400/8780blackcoin.co/-/issues/1


https://git.zazahome.kr/alexiscambell


https://git.agri-sys.com/alfredo7273403

References:


gitea.adminakademia.pl
20 November 2025 07:54
#91   Will
      
https://connectthelinks.com/brittnylowes6


https://deepdiverse.online/employer/dine/


https://beshortlisted.com/employer/7bit-casino-usa-slots-live-dealer-games-and-f
ast-payouts-online/


https://ezonnerecruit.com/employer/cashman-casino-welcome-bonus-claim-100-free-c
oins-today/


https://audiorooms-radio.de/douglassuttor


https://blogs.koreaportal.com/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=6659755


https://khongdaidong.click/lohlelia596879


https://some.center/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=793354


https://cz-link.click/eliseblg426750


https://xtrainkom.com/employer/best-real-money-online-casinos-in-the-us-2025/


https://talentrendezvous.com/companies/cashman-casino-review-a-vibrant-online-ga
ming-experience/


https://whsp.red/lanewalder6568


http://hi-d.co.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=427170


https://jobsinodisha.org/companies/play-royal-slots-win-today/


https://jobs.khtp.com.my/employer/9147/cashman-casino-unveils-faster-login-proce
ss-for-instant-slot-access/


https://allgovtjobz.pk/companies/official-website/


https://audiorooms-radio.de/janilevine2209


https://behired.eu/employer/cashman-casino-unveils-faster-login-process-for-inst
ant-slot-access/


https://fanajobs.com/profile/torymessner819


https://smartcard.phoenixopia.com/viviancooley61


https://epsart.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=1194

References:


trainersjunction.com
19 November 2025 23:46
#90   Terese
      
https://mp3diary.com/lachlanpatters


https://www.first315.com/armandtang257/armand2008/wiki/Map+of+Casino%252C+NSW+24
70


https://kayesbamusic.com/georginajeffer


https://www.chaorendata.shop/harriettperry/blackcoin.co1984/wiki/Casino+Royale+L
as+Vegas+closing+possible%252C+but+not+confirmed


https://date4you.de/@josefangeles3


https://git.zhongjie51.com/jolenemichael


https://zurimeet.com/@blainemeadows


https://onetouch-git.thxpace.com/alejandrinawic/9832496/-/issues/1


https://git.nusaerp.com/amparocreighto


https://www.cloud.file.futurestack.cn/benniesealey42/blackcoin2138/wiki/Online+C
asinos+for+USA+Players+Play+at+Trusted+US+Casino+Sites


https://git.kirasparkle.de/anneliesefrahm


https://mockway.cpolar.top/deweybartos396


https://gogs.optch.top/agneswarkentin/3561655/wiki/King+Billy+Casino+Bonuses+for
+Every+Royal+Player


https://theindievibes.com/zoqevan2876553


https://gitea.nongnghiepso.com/andersonlightf


https://nrimatchmaking.com/@alana26078789


https://karr83.world/read-blog/1593_play-over-5000-pokies-enjoy-fast-withdrawals
-24-7-support-and-top-tier-security.html


http://106.55.174.214:3000/christytavares/blackcoin.co4683/wiki/New-Online-Casin
os-in-Australia%3A-Top-10-Picks-for-2025


https://gitea.alaindee.net/krystynalevvy/5910blackcoin/wiki/Rocketplay-casino-Au
stralia


http://47.102.209.69:53000/macn6624331628/4017blackcoin.co/wiki/Crown-Casino-Per
th-blackjack-games


https://gogs.optch.top/tiffanymarcus

References:


testgitea.educoder.net

https://git2.ujin.tech/leonidalair267


https://quickplay.pro/celsaflz098146


https://pilowtalks.com/@sandrareading5


https://lesla.com/@daneklinger954


https://gitea.pnkx.top:8/autumnsteffey5


https://quickdatescript.com/@annie528927757


https://zurimeet.com/@vitomendoza383


https://gitea.visoftware.com.co/numbersmonaco5


https://gogs.pinadshub.com/charitylouise8/charity1989/wiki/Safe+%2526+Rewarding+
Online+Gaming+USA


https://nrimatchmaking.com/@monamendelsohn


http://122.51.6.97:3000/tracie2235888


https://git.ecq.jp/hattiewooley1


https://vila.go.ro/abdulclaypool5


https://volts.howto.co.ug/@neva564025144


https://twoheartsagency.com/@bethhunsicker9


https://hub.hdc-smart.com/broderickrwj32


https://gitea.potatox.net/alfredomaum598/blackcoin1634/wiki/Premium-Online-Gamin
g-Experience-in-Australia


https://napvibe.com/read-blog/58229_official-online-casino-website-in-australia-
2025.html


https://git.fandiyuan.com/elbertchung27


https://ophiuchus.wiki/bobbynewbigin4/5476392/wiki/Top-5-sweepstakes-casinos-in-
November-2025%3A-Get-a-free-no-deposit-bonus-%26-more


https://qrew.social/read-blog/10732_crown-towers-sydney-review-hotel-delivers-th
e-wow-factor-city-has-been-missing.html

References:


git.ides.club
18 November 2025 02:08
#89   Eloisa
      
https://gogs.koljastrohm-games.com/delorespeterse


https://gitea.jobiglo.com/alihodgson220


https://phoebe.roshka.com/gitlab/bobbiethompkin


https://gogs.pinadshub.com/charitylouise8/charity1989/wiki/Safe+%2526+Rewarding+
Online+Gaming+USA


https://gitea.freeyoursystem.de/blanchemarriot


https://gitlab.ngser.com/venusgollan054/blackcoin3662/-/issues/1


https://git.olyntec.com/tarenreichstei


https://gitea.micro-stack.org/anaathaldo0644


https://giteap.grobest.com:3000/margotbalcombe/margot1994/wiki/The-Best-Online-C
asino-Choices-in-Australia


https://trackrecord.id/read-blog/39775_get-up-to-ca-7500-bonus.html


https://jamboz.com/read-blog/51811_crowncoinscasino-review-amp-my-verdict-is-it-
legit.html


https://git.ecq.jp/adalombardo024


http://git.guaiyun.com.cn/marcelino1429/blackcoin.co8279/wiki/SkyCrown-Australia
-Casino-Premium-Online-Gaming-Experience-in-Australia


https://www.musicsound.ca/antjehickman87


https://net.smartedge.com.ng/read-blog/9979_get-8-000-400-fs-on-registration.htm
l


https://git.ides.club/adolphprout189


https://galaxybook.net/read-blog/76_sky-crown-casino-australia-%E1%90%89-games-b
onuses-payments-and-support.html


https://git.ecq.jp/jonahdorron61/jonah1989/wiki/2024-Best-AU-Casinos


https://www.musicsound.ca/lillianathiess


https://go.atamarii.com/@wendivlamingh


https://git.deadpoo.net/joni46e3789868

References:


https://www.jokkey.com/jacquesaugusti
18 November 2025 00:58
#88   Lionel
      
https://git.getmind.cn/lynned22282250


https://naijasingles.net/@serenasasaki78


https://www.first315.com/fernerapp11198


https://niubillity.com:3000/leovallecillo/9640086/wiki/SkyCrown+Casino+Australia



https://git.rbsx.de/armandochacon


https://git.repo.in.net/carmenlindeman


http://47.102.209.69:53000/fostermyrick5/blackcoin.co8971/wiki/WA-government-say
s-Crown-Perth-a-%27suitable-entity%27-to-operate-casino%2C-three-years-on-from-r
oyal-commission


https://vcs.int.feuerwehr-ziemetshausen.de/linkulikowski


https://datingmywish.com/@miguelkell4329


https://gogs.zfire.top/brodieong65018/8028382/wiki/Best+Online+Casino+Australia+
2025+Top+Online+Casino+Sites


https://katambe.com/@chanaromano176


https://schokigeschmack.de/fletchervidal9


https://twitxme.com/read-blog/176_gonza-bet-casino-review-expert-amp-player-rati
ngs-2025.html


https://asfuyao.top:8300/wallyschonell3


http://huaang6688.gnway.cc:3000/cindimacdevitt/1089827/wiki/Join+Now+%2526+Claim
+Your+Bonus%2521


https://leafreward.com/read-blog/7181_ignition-casino-no-deposit-bonus-3000-welc
ome-bonus.html


https://volts.howto.co.ug/@dewittboston1


https://phoebe.roshka.com/gitlab/stocarri885154


https://voicync.com/howardstedman


https://gitea.pnkx.top:8/adrienenrz094


https://gitea.mocup.org/beatrissolis5

References:


https://git.sudo-fhir.au/
18 November 2025 00:44
#87   Estelle
      
how much hgh to take for bodybuilding

References:


viewcinema.ru
13 November 2025 19:32
#86   Wanda
      
why sytropin hgh

References:


niacin hgh (https://eskisehiruroloji.com)
12 November 2025 01:54
#85   Larue
      
is hgh testosterone

References:


Iu To Mg Hgh (E1Adphegqz7E.рф)
7 November 2025 07:16
#84   Gustavo
      
hgh 2 iu per day

References:


hgh Only cycle [Historydb.date]
7 November 2025 07:09
#83   Chelsey
      
hgh how many iu's per day

References:


hgh injections Side effects (rentry.co)
7 November 2025 06:52
#82   Sherryl
      
before and after hgh

References:


6iu hgh (odvinsk.ru)
7 November 2025 06:03
#81   Dwight
      
difference between testosterone and hgh

References:


Hgh Dosage Iu Bodybuilding (Https://Carroll-Holmberg.Blogbright.Net)
7 November 2025 05:54
#80   Grace
      
hgh skin before and after

References:


hgh dosage for fat Loss (41-4lcpj.укр)
7 November 2025 05:42
#79   Eartha
      
best anabolic steroid for cutting

References:


play.ntop.tv
7 November 2025 05:23
#78   Neal
      
fat burning steroids

References:


pad.stuve.uni-ulm.de
7 November 2025 03:03
#77   Gertie
      
is hgh the same as testosterone

References:


Hgh FüR Frauen (Bleezlabs.Com)
6 November 2025 21:51
Add Comments

Name:*
E-Mail:
  Geo Keyboard  
 

Dear reader, guardian.ge welcomes your comments. Please express your views on topic and be respectful of others.

bold italic underline strike | align left centered align right | Ensert smilies insert linkInsert protected URL Choice the color | hidden text insert quote Convert selected text from transliteration to Cyrillic alphabet Insert spoiler

Code: *


Back1 ... 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11Next